The Question Raised by the Roh So-young and Chey Tae-won Case
66.5 billion won at the first instance, 1.38 trillion won on appeal. When it became known that property division in the same case could vary this dramatically, many people began asking, what exactly is the standard for property division in Korea? Having handled family cases for many years, I generally encourage couples to pursue uncontested or mediated divorce rather than litigation. But even in an uncontested divorce, you need to know how assets would be divided if the case went to trial in order to negotiate at all. This article organizes the general standards for property division at a glance.
Comparison Abroad: The California Standard
In the United States, property division laws vary by state. California follows this general framework:
- Property held before marriage and property received by gift or inheritance during marriage: treated as separate property and excluded from division
- Property formed during marriage: divided equally 50-50 in principle
The biggest difference from Korea is that the standard is relatively clear. Of course, in actual trials there are disputes over whether a given asset is separate property, but the starting point in the statute is unambiguous.
The Korean Statute: The Court Decides
Article 839-2(2) of the Civil Code provides that when an agreement is not reached or cannot be reached, the Family Court determines the amount and method of division, considering the value of property formed through the cooperation of both parties and other circumstances. Article 843 applies the same provision to judicial divorce. In other words, the court decides at its discretion. So in Korea, case law and practice effectively function as the standard, rather than the statute itself. Even for the same facts, outcomes can vary widely depending on the panel and the litigation strategy.
The Framework Established by Case Law
One spouse separate property is in principle not subject to division, but if the other spouse is recognized as having contributed to its maintenance or increase, it may become subject to division.
This holding is the starting point of Korean property division. Even for real estate received by inheritance or gift, if the spouse contributed directly or indirectly through household labor during the marriage, that property can be drawn into the division pool. Property received as a gift from a third party tends to be evaluated through the same lens.
Core Concept 1: What Is Special Property
Special property means:
- Property held by one spouse before marriage
- Property acquired by one spouse through inheritance or gift during marriage
In principle it is not subject to division, but if the other spouse contribution is recognized, it can be partially drawn into the division pool. The same standard applies broadly to bank deposits, stocks, and business interests, not just real estate.
Core Concept 2: Length of Marriage and Inclusion of Special Property
At lower-court practice, the following trends are typically observed:
- When the marriage lasts roughly three years or more, even pre-marital property tends to be drawn into the division pool
- The longer the marriage, the higher the division share assigned to the other spouse against the special property
Special property that started at 100-0 gets adjusted to 90-10, 80-20, 70-30, gradually entering the division pool. The three-year figure is not an absolute rule but a general trend line, and inclusion can happen earlier or later depending on the case facts.
Core Concept 3: Division Ratio for Ordinary Marital Property
Property formed during marriage that is not special property tends to be divided equally 50-50 in principle.
- This principle generally holds even if one spouse is a stay-at-home spouse (whether husband or wife)
- Even when exceptions apply, the range is typically 40-60, and at most 35-65 in very exceptional cases
Extreme divisions like 20-80 or 10-90 are generally not recognized. The 50-50 principle starts from the view that household labor and child-rearing are non-monetary contributions to marital asset formation.
Worked Example: A Couple in Their Seventh Year of Marriage
Assume A and B have been married for seven years.
- A property in A name: 100 million won (held before marriage), A is a stay-at-home spouse
- B property in B name: 200 million won (formed during marriage through earned income)
A 100 million won is special property, but given the seven-year marriage, part of it is typically drawn into the division pool. If we assume the total marital wealth of 300 million won is divided about 60-40 between A and B, A receives 180 million won and B receives 120 million won. Since B currently holds 200 million won in name, B owes A 80 million won as a property division payment. Of course, the ratio can shift with specific circumstances. In the same scenario, if B incurred large business debt, net asset calculation changes; if A household and child-rearing contribution is strongly proven, the ratio may go higher.
Most Important Steps in Practice
- Classify each spouse property as special property or ordinary marital property
- Evaluate the other spouse contribution (maintenance and increase) to the special property
- Apply the 50-50 baseline for ordinary marital property, with adjustments
- Also account for debts and liabilities to compute net assets
- Determine valuations as of the valuation date (typically the date of closing argument)
Factors That Shift the Division Ratio
- Length of the marriage
- Degree of proof for non-monetary contributions such as household labor and child-rearing
- Direct efforts to form assets (self-employment, employment)
- How debts were incurred and how they were used
- One spouse business failure, wastage, or other negative conduct
- Allocation of childcare responsibilities
These factors are meaningful only when proven by evidence at the trial stage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Can special property be included in division even before the three-year mark? A. Three years is a general trend line, not an absolute rule. Even with a shorter marriage, if the other spouse concrete contribution is clear, the property can be drawn in. Conversely, even past three years, inclusion may not occur depending on circumstances.
Q. Can a stay-at-home spouse also receive a 50-50 division? A. Generally that trend holds. Household labor and child-rearing by a stay-at-home spouse are evaluated as cooperation in forming marital property. However, the ratio is often adjusted in cases where one spouse special property makes up a large share.
Q. Do I need to know property division standards even for an uncontested divorce? A. Yes. Even in uncontested divorces, if the agreement deviates significantly from typical division standards, post-divorce disputes can easily arise. Knowing the standard that would apply in litigation is what makes a balanced agreement possible.
Closing
The standard for property division ultimately combines whether the asset is special property and what kind of contribution existed during the marriage. Whether you proceed by agreement or litigation, organizing which category your assets fall into before consulting tends to make the consultation far more efficient.
Author: Attorney Yoon Ji-sang / Last reviewed 2026-05-30
Disclaimer: This article summarizes general standards and flow of divorce property division and is not legal advice on any specific case. Facts and outcomes can vary by case, so please consult an attorney directly for specific matters.



